Covet thy neighbors....hat?
-
cdavis don’t know how I missed this reply! Yeah he was a brute! We actually harvested another buck that was related to him as it had a rack very similar. Had it scored a long time ago and they admitted they didn’t really score it correctly. It wasn’t a Boone and Crockett scorer. It does have a ton of bone though! Mine was pretty typical. He went 156! My brother has a monster that was well over 180 gross. I like gross score. Give them credit for what they grow!
ND Mike I’m with you gross score only. Why would you subtract from what they grew
. Makes no sense to me. 
. My best gross scored 193. -
ND Mike I’m with you gross score only. Why would you subtract from what they grew
. Makes no sense to me. . My best gross scored 193.cdavis That is something to be proud of, though I think just getting a deer is something to be proud of because of all the wonderful great meat.
-
cdavis That is something to be proud of, though I think just getting a deer is something to be proud of because of all the wonderful great meat.
bocephus I agree with you 100%. I’m proud of everyone I ever harvested. No matter how small. When I was younger that meat got me through some pretty rough times.
-
ND Mike I’m with you gross score only. Why would you subtract from what they grew
. Makes no sense to me. . My best gross scored 193.cdavis that is a toad!!! Holy smokes!!!
-
ND Mike I’m with you gross score only. Why would you subtract from what they grew
. Makes no sense to me. . My best gross scored 193.cdavis I’m curious what an average good sized buck field dresses out at down there? Up here a good big buck will be around 200 lbs field dressed. We have harvested about 10 that were 220-240 lbs though.
-
cdavis I’m curious what an average good sized buck field dresses out at down there? Up here a good big buck will be around 200 lbs field dressed. We have harvested about 10 that were 220-240 lbs though.
ND Mike said in Covet thy neighbors....hat?:
cdavis I’m curious what an average good sized buck field dresses out at down there? Up here a good big buck will be around 200 lbs field dressed. We have harvested about 10 that were 220-240 lbs though.
That sounds pretty consistent for weight on a healthy mature whitetail buck in this part of the midwest as well. Mature being one that survives to 3 1/2 years and beyond.
The further North the whitetail deer live, the heavier the mature weight seems to trend.
-
cdavis I’m curious what an average good sized buck field dresses out at down there? Up here a good big buck will be around 200 lbs field dressed. We have harvested about 10 that were 220-240 lbs though.
ND Mike our mature bucks don’t carry that kind of body weight. Here they average 150 to 170. You still see a few above the average. I killed this buck the first day of bow season last year and after field dressing he weighed 196lbs. He made the other bucks he was with look tiny. Also it was before he could run all the fat off during the rut.
-
ND Mike said in Covet thy neighbors....hat?:
cdavis I’m curious what an average good sized buck field dresses out at down there? Up here a good big buck will be around 200 lbs field dressed. We have harvested about 10 that were 220-240 lbs though.
That sounds pretty consistent for weight on a healthy mature whitetail buck in this part of the midwest as well. Mature being one that survives to 3 1/2 years and beyond.
The further North the whitetail deer live, the heavier the mature weight seems to trend.
processhead yep for sure. I know I have seen some that are over 300 lbs on the hoof. ND whitetails are the same subspecies as the deer in Manitoba and Saskatchewan.
-
ND Mike our mature bucks don’t carry that kind of body weight. Here they average 150 to 170. You still see a few above the average. I killed this buck the first day of bow season last year and after field dressing he weighed 196lbs. He made the other bucks he was with look tiny. Also it was before he could run all the fat off during the rut.
cdavis that’s a good deer too! I wish we would’ve weighed the one my brother shot last year. It is the heaviest deer we have ever had. He had one about 8 years ago that was 232 field dressed. He won the big buck contest for weight that year. He’s actually won it about 5 times. I have won the biggest doe contest 4 times. I shot a doe with a muzzleloader that field dressed at 165 lbs! She was aged at 7 1/2 years old!!!
-
cdavis that’s a good deer too! I wish we would’ve weighed the one my brother shot last year. It is the heaviest deer we have ever had. He had one about 8 years ago that was 232 field dressed. He won the big buck contest for weight that year. He’s actually won it about 5 times. I have won the biggest doe contest 4 times. I shot a doe with a muzzleloader that field dressed at 165 lbs! She was aged at 7 1/2 years old!!!
ND Mike wow those are some huge deer. It’s almost cheating. I have to kill 2 deer to get the same amount of meat yall get out of 1. Good luck this season maybe you’ll knock your brother out of that big buck contest
. -
Any whitetail that dresses out at 200 lbs or above is above average. Those are all very nice deer pictured and anyone would be proud to have taken them.
-
ND Mike wow those are some huge deer. It’s almost cheating. I have to kill 2 deer to get the same amount of meat yall get out of 1. Good luck this season maybe you’ll knock your brother out of that big buck contest
.cdavis good luck to you! I got turned down on my buck tag but got a doe tag. I am planning on using my Grandpa’s Winchester 30-30 that he gave me to harvest my doe tag. That is if I can find some 30-30 shells!
-
Any whitetail that dresses out at 200 lbs or above is above average. Those are all very nice deer pictured and anyone would be proud to have taken them.
bocephus yep for sure. Good meat for the freezer!
-
cdavis good luck to you! I got turned down on my buck tag but got a doe tag. I am planning on using my Grandpa’s Winchester 30-30 that he gave me to harvest my doe tag. That is if I can find some 30-30 shells!
ND Mike thank you sir. I just bought 5 boxes of 30 30s from optics planet.com. They were really reasonable with fast shipping. I’ve bought a lot of ammo from them lately.
-
cdavis good luck to you! I got turned down on my buck tag but got a doe tag. I am planning on using my Grandpa’s Winchester 30-30 that he gave me to harvest my doe tag. That is if I can find some 30-30 shells!
ND Mike sorry about your buck tag. I sometimes forget some people have to draw for them. We’re lucky here we get 2 buck tags and 4 doe tags.
-
ND Mike thank you sir. I just bought 5 boxes of 30 30s from optics planet.com. They were really reasonable with fast shipping. I’ve bought a lot of ammo from them lately.
cdavis I will have to look into that!
-
ND Mike sorry about your buck tag. I sometimes forget some people have to draw for them. We’re lucky here we get 2 buck tags and 4 doe tags.
cdavis that sure would be nice. I fear our tags are really going to be reduced next year. We are have had a huge EHD outbreak! They are finding hundreds upon hundreds of dead deer.
-
cdavis that sure would be nice. I fear our tags are really going to be reduced next year. We are have had a huge EHD outbreak! They are finding hundreds upon hundreds of dead deer.
ND Mike I just pray that never happens here. We have a really healthy deer herd. The only time I hear about around here it’s the pen raised deer and they are really strict about the way they are disposed of.
-
ND Mike I just pray that never happens here. We have a really healthy deer herd. The only time I hear about around here it’s the pen raised deer and they are really strict about the way they are disposed of.
cdavis they are blaming it on our drought. EHD is caused by the bite of a midge (gnat). First killing frost will stop it. Luckily CWD is limited to only a few units in the West.
-
cdavis they are blaming it on our drought. EHD is caused by the bite of a midge (gnat). First killing frost will stop it. Luckily CWD is limited to only a few units in the West.
ND Mike isn’t ehd the same as blue tongue.
Hello! It looks like you're interested in this conversation, but you don't have an account yet.
Getting fed up of having to scroll through the same posts each visit? When you register for an account, you'll always come back to exactly where you were before, and choose to be notified of new replies (either via email, or push notification). You'll also be able to save bookmarks and upvote posts to show your appreciation to other community members.
With your input, this post could be even better 💗
Register LoginSponsored By:
